Dutch Bros Growth Soars, Starbucks Faces Sales Struggles

Dutch Bros stock has surged 98% in the past year, driven by rapid expansion and a strong customer focus. Meanwhile, Starbucks faces a decline in same-store sales, reflecting industry challenges. Which company offers better investment potential amid this volatility?

Date: 26-04-2025

AI Rating: 7

Growth Potential of Dutch Bros
Dutch Bros (NYSE: BROS) has seen remarkable growth over the past year, with stock prices up 98%. The coffeehouse chain is focusing on rapid expansion, aiming for a total of 7,000 locations—up from an initial target of 4,000. This expansion idea considerably enhances revenue prospects and net income potential, provided management executes the growth strategy effectively. The company's focus on drive-through convenience and customization aligns well with consumer preferences, boosting its chances for sustained growth.

Challenges Faced by Starbucks
In contrast, Starbucks (NASDAQ: SBUX) has reported a worrying trend with a 4% decline in same-store sales for the fiscal 2025 first quarter. This marks the fourth consecutive quarter of year-over-year declines, raising significant concerns about customer retention amidst rising prices and wait times. Mr. Niccol, the CEO, is attempting to revitalize Starbucks by enhancing the customer experience and addressing these operational concerns. Despite the current challenges, the company is projected to see a 24% growth in earnings per share (EPS) for fiscal 2026. This is a positive indication, although the current state raises questions about its immediate recovery in a fiercely competitive market.

Conclusion for Investors
Investors face contrasting scenarios with these two coffee giants. Dutch Bros presents a compelling growth story fueled by aggressive expansion and increasing market presence. However, its valuation (P/E ratio of 174) raises questions about sustainability if profits do not grow in alignment with its ambitious plans. On the other hand, Starbucks retains an economic moat and brand recognition, which provides it with advantages in tough times. The eventual recovery seen in EPS could potentially make Starbucks a safer bet for conservative investors.
In summary, while Dutch Bros offers potentially higher upside amidst rapid growth, its execution risks are worth considering. Starbucks, while currently struggling, may present a more stable investment with the potential for gradual recovery.

Stocks: BROS SBUX