Carvana's Turnaround Faces New Risks Amid Financial Challenges

In a report on Carvana's recent performance and challenges, the online auto retailer has seen a remarkable rise of over 228% in stock price this year amid a robust recovery. However, potential risks concerning poor-performing loans and debt obligations could impact future performance.

Date: 23-09-2024

AI Rating: 5

Carvana has emerged as one of the standout stocks of 2024, boasting a significant increase of 228% thus far. The company's recovery follows a near-bankruptcy stage, and it has achieved improving quarterly results that have caught investors' attention. However, new concerns are arising that might deter investment.

One of the positive aspects highlighted is Carvana's gross profit per unit (GPPU), which saw a year-over-year increase of 28% to $3,421 in the second quarter. This performance outshines not only its past results but also those of competitors like CarMax, which posted a GPPU of $2,347. Additionally, Carvana’s retail volumes have rebounded significantly, with unit sales increasing 16% year-over-year in Q1 and a remarkable 33% in Q2. While these figures suggest strong demand, revenue growth has lagged at 15%, indicating that lower-priced vehicles have been a major contributing factor.

However, concerns are rising due to the company’s reliance on finance receivables sales, particularly to Ally Financial, which is facing increasing delinquencies in car loans. If Ally renegotiates the terms or withdraws, it could severely impact Carvana’s revenue stream from these channels. This could lead to lower profit margins, given that a significant portion of Carvana’s sales are tied to third-party loans.

Additionally, Carvana's long-term debt remains substantial at $5.4 billion, with free cash flow reflecting the pressure on the company. Although it generated $415 million in free cash flow, this number is dramatically reduced when considering cash interest payments on its debt, marking only $130 million. This creates a precarious financial position where the company relies on high-margin financial products.

As a potential investor, the duality of Carvana's current growth juxtaposed with these financial red flags presents a high-risk situation. Relying on improving economic conditions and maintaining customer credit health will be crucial for sustaining future growth.

Stocks: CVNA ALLY